They're No Manolos

I know, I know, I don't have a wedding dress so what the heck am I doing buying shoes?!  Not to worry, I haven't bought my shoe's yet. You know, the HAWT pink ones I'll have on me when I walk to down the aisle. I bought my reception shoes! I am in no way a "shoe person"-unlike my sister who believes in the motto, "You cannot have too many shoes, ever". I consider myself a purse collector. I love kate spade! I have one pair of dressy Tommy Hilfiger sandals and all of the rest of my shoes are the chunky boot-looking kind. I also have a pair of all black Adidas sandals that I used to chase Morgan around in last summer. I spend most of my time in sneakers but I knew I didn't want to do that for the wedding. This was an important day so I wanted to do a little something out of the normal, yet comfortable, and still within my tomboy-esque comfort zone. I had to come up with something that was a little of both, and then I laid my eyes on these....

Source

Oh yes, they are everything I never knew I always wanted in my reception foot gear. They are pink & black which are our wedding colors, they are soooo comfy, and they are in typical Michele taste. I bought them right then and there. I know I will wear these bad boys no matter what happens, (can you feel the impulse buyers remorse coming on?)  but in searching online for a good picture of my shoes, I came across something else that I'm thinking maybe a little more fitting for the occasion.

Source

These look a little bit more bridal I think. So here it is, do I stick with what I have, or do I buy the pink & white ones which would also increase my sad and pathetic little shoe collection? Are you wearing something non-wedding-ish on your toes during the reception?